How to Build an Xactimate Roof Estimate for Insurance Supplements
Kelvin Spratt
Founder, Supplement Snap · March 7, 2026
Key Takeaways
How to build an Xactimate-format roof estimate for insurance supplements: common line items, how to structure each line, price lists and the mistakes that get supplements denied.
Preparing a supplement? Use the free checklist so nothing is missing when you submit.
What is Xactimate and why does it matter for roofing supplements?
Xactimate is the insurance industry's standard software for estimating property damage repair costs. Developed by Verisk, Verisk says most of the largest property insurers use it, along with many independent adjusters and third-party administrators to write estimates for roofing claims. When an adjuster inspects storm damage on a roof, they enter their findings into Xactimate using standardized line codes, unit prices, and quantities to produce the claim estimate.
For roofing contractors, Xactimate matters because it is the language adjusters speak. When you submit a supplement (a request for additional payment for hidden damage found during tear-off), the adjuster needs to process that request within Xactimate. If your supplement is written in Xactimate's format with the correct line codes and pricing, the adjuster can review and approve it quickly. If your supplement is a vague description with a few photos and no reference to Xactimate codes, the adjuster has to do extra work to translate your findings, which often results in lower approvals, longer processing times, or outright denials.
You don't need to own an Xactimate license to submit supplements in Xactimate format. What you need is knowledge of the relevant line codes, the unit prices for your area, and how to structure your findings so the adjuster can process them efficiently.

How adjusters use Xactimate to write roof estimates
Understanding how adjusters use Xactimate helps you write better supplements. When an adjuster inspects a roof for storm damage, they follow a systematic process:
They measure the roof or use a measurement report (EagleView, Hover, etc.)
They inspect the roof surface for hail impacts, wind damage, or other covered perils
They enter their findings into Xactimate as line items, each with a specific code, quantity, and unit price
Xactimate calculates overhead and profit (O&P) on top of the line items, often 10% overhead and 10% profit, though the carrier and the claim decide what is allowed
The software generates a detailed estimate that becomes the basis for the claim payment
The adjuster's Xactimate estimate only includes what they could see during their inspection. They walked the roof, noted visible damage, and wrote line items for the repairs they observed. They did not tear off the shingles. They did not inspect the decking underneath. They did not check the condition of the flashing behind the step metal or the integrity of the ice and water shield in the valleys.
This is exactly why supplements exist. The adjuster's estimate is based on a surface inspection. Your supplement adds the concealed damage that only becomes visible during tear-off. The more closely your supplement mirrors the adjuster's Xactimate format, the easier it is for them to approve the additional items.
Common line items for roofing supplements
Every supplement item should match a line item in the adjuster's estimate format. These come up often, and each is counted the way noted. This page does not list Xactimate item codes or prices: we could not verify them against Xactimate's own price list, and both vary by price list, region and date. Look up the exact item and price in your own software or on the adjuster's estimate.
Sheathing (plywood/OSB), remove and replace: for rotted or damaged roof decking. Counted by area. A standard 4x8 sheet is 32 SF.
Step/counter flashing, remove and replace: for corroded or damaged step flashing at chimneys, walls and dormers. Counted by length.
Ice and water shield membrane, install: used when it is missing in code-required areas or has deteriorated. Counted by area. This item often requires a building code reference in your narrative.
Roof vents and pipe jacks/boots, remove and replace: for cracked or deteriorated pipe boots. Counted individually.
Drip edge, remove and replace: used when it is missing or damaged. Counted by length.
Removal of an additional layer of roofing: used when a second or third layer is discovered during tear-off. Counted by roof area.
Looking for the full roofing supplement list? See 12 items contractors commonly request and the Xactimate roofing supplement list quick reference.
Building a supplement estimate in Xactimate format
You don't need to own Xactimate to submit a professional supplement. What you need is a structured document that mirrors the Xactimate format so the adjuster can process it quickly.
For each finding, include these elements:
Line code: the item code from your own price list
Description: the item description as your price list words it
Quantity: the measured amount in the correct unit (for example 96 SF)
Unit: the unit the item uses in your price list
Unit price: the price from the price list named on the adjuster's estimate
Line total: quantity multiplied by unit price
Here is the layout of one line, with the code and price left for you to fill in from your price list:
[code from your price list] | Sheathing, plywood/OSB, R&R | 96 SF | [unit price] | [quantity x unit price]
This level of specificity makes it easy for the adjuster to review. Compare it with a supplement that just says 'additional decking and flashing needed - $1,500.' Which version is easier to review?
Pricing and regional variations
Xactimate pricing is not fixed nationally. Prices come from price lists that vary by region and change over time, so a contractor in Dallas will see different unit prices than one in Minneapolis. This page does not give price ranges, because we could not verify any against a documented price source.
When submitting a supplement, use the price list named on the adjuster's estimate so your lines can be compared with theirs one by one, and do not mix price lists.
Overhead and profit (O&P) is a separate discussion. Whether it is allowed depends on the carrier, the policy and the claim, so ask whether it applies to your supplement if the original estimate includes it.
Mistakes that get Xactimate supplements denied
Even with the right line codes and pricing, supplements get denied for avoidable mistakes:
Wrong quantities: Claiming 5 sheets of decking when your photos only show 2 damaged areas. Adjusters cross-reference your quantities against the photos. Always measure carefully and photograph every area you're claiming.
Missing documentation: Submitting line items without supporting photos or a narrative. The adjuster needs to justify the additional payment to their supervisor. Give them the evidence they need.
Using incorrect codes: Selecting the wrong Xactimate code changes the unit price and signals you don't know what you're doing. Know your codes.
Not explaining concealment: Your narrative must clearly state that the damage was concealed beneath existing roofing materials and was discovered during tear-off operations. Without this, the adjuster may argue it should have been caught during the initial inspection.
Late submission: Submitting a supplement three weeks after tear-off raises questions. Why did it take so long? Has the damage been covered by new materials? Submit the same day whenever possible.
Inflated pricing: Submitting prices above the current Xactimate rate for your region signals you're padding the estimate and makes the adjuster scrutinize every line item.
How Supplement Snap builds an Xactimate-style starting list
Building an Xactimate-formatted supplement manually for every job takes time: looking up line codes, checking pricing, formatting the estimate, writing the narrative, organizing photos. It's the kind of work that either falls on your office staff or doesn't get done at all.
Supplement Snap automates this process. Your crew captures damage findings during tear-off: photos tagged by damage type, roof area selected, and a voice note describing what they found. Voice notes work in Spanish and other supported languages, so Spanish-speaking crews describe findings naturally and the system auto-translates to English.
Supplement Snap's Xactimate-style CSV (Team and Pro plans) is a starting list of items for you to review. Check each item and enter the item codes and prices from your own price list before you rely on it. The file has not been tested through an Xactimate import.
The result is a supplement that speaks the adjuster's language, includes the evidence they need, and arrives the same day the damage was found. That combination (clear format, strong documentation, fast submission) is what gives a supplement its best chance of a fair review.
For how each item is counted and what proof to attach, see our Xactimate roofing supplement items guide.
References & Resources
Free tools and resources
Ready to streamline your supplement process?
Supplement Snap helps your crew capture hidden damage during tear-off and generate adjuster-ready reports in minutes.
Written by
Kelvin Spratt
Founder, Supplement Snap
Kelvin builds Supplement Snap, the roofing documentation software this site promotes. Articles are published by Supplement Snap, which has a commercial interest in the topics covered. They are general information, not legal, insurance or claims advice. About Supplement Snap